Payments To make a payment, click on the names below for phone numbers and links. Insurer Contact Information Farmers Personal (888) 327-6335https://www.farmers.com/css/payment/findpolicy Farmers Business (855) 323-5350https://www.farmers.com/onetime-payment/ Bristol West (888) 888-0080https://www.bristolwest.com/payments Foremost (800) 532-4221https://www.myforemostaccount.com/fmcss/login?ref=fpo Progressive 888-671-4405Click Here for Online Payment